| PlayerName | Opponents | First Season | Last Season |
|---|---|---|---|
| Murphy | DARTFORD | 1893-94 | 1893-94 |
| Murphy | GLOSSOP | 1902-03 | 1902-03 |
| Murphy | QUEENS PARK RANGERS | 1903-04 | 1905-06 |
| Murphy | LUTON TOWN | 1906-07 | 1906-07 |
| Murphy | BARRY TOWN | 1938-39 | 1938-39 |
| Murphy | EXETER CITY RESERVES | 1949-50 | 1949-50 |